Blackadder is one of those British comedies that gets funnier every time I rewatch it. Baldrick’s ideas get more questionable, Edmund Blackadder’s insults get sharper, and the changing historical settings keep each series feeling fresh and completely different. I’ve watched every episode from each Blackadder series more times than I can count. That puts me in a solid spot to break down what makes each series unique and help you figure out which one is best for different comedy styles.
What Sets Blackadder Apart From Other Comedy Series?
Blackadder isn’t your run-of-the-mill sitcom. Over four main series (plus some specials), the show hops across different historical periods. Each one gives us a fresh take, with Rowan Atkinson as Edmund Blackadder and Tony Robinson as Baldrick, usually finding new ways to land in trouble. Most shows stick to the same dynamic and setting, but Blackadder likes to mix things up with a new variation of the main character and a distinct angle in every era.
The constant switch up is part of its appeal. The series covers everything from the Middle Ages to World War I, showcasing dry wit, wordplay, and absurd scheming. Even if you’re just starting to check out British comedy, the range across Blackadder’s four series makes it perfect for repeat watches and debates about which historical era lands the most jokes.
The Four Blackadder Series: A Quick Overview
- The Black Adder (Series 1) – 1983: This kicks things off in the medieval era after the Wars of the Roses.
- Blackadder II – 1986: Takes a wild jump to the reign of Queen Elizabeth I.
- Blackadder the Third – 1987: Moves to Regency England, with Blackadder serving as a butler for the Prince Regent.
- Blackadder Goes Forth – 1989: Drops us straight into the trenches of World War I.
While these might seem like four different shows, each season offers its own clever spin on the servant-master dynamic and keeps the dark, tongue-in-cheek humor rolling strong that has made Blackadder iconic.
How Each Series Stands Out
Every series has its own mood, comedic style, and pace. Here’s how each one breaks down in my experience:
The Black Adder (Series 1): The Oddball Origin
The first series feels completely different from the later ones. Prince Edmund (the Black Adder) is bumbling, cowardly, and not even a little bit as sharp as his future versions. The jokes lean broad, the stories rely on visual gags, and the medieval setting gives the show a wacky, over-the-top edge. Some people find the pacing a bit slow or less polished, but the series has its own quirky charm. It’s packed with medieval castles, scheming nobles, and a delightfully dysfunctional royal family.
The first series gets less credit because it differs so much in style and tone. Still, it’s worth checking out if you’re curious about Blackadder’s beginning and want to catch Rowan Atkinson going full-on goofy before he evolves into his more refined, snarky character.
Blackadder II: The Leap Into Classic Wit
Blackadder II is, in my view, where the show finds its stride. Atkinson’s Blackadder switches into a fast-talking, cynical advisor in the court of Queen Elizabeth I (Miranda Richardson). The writing becomes even sharper, with quick banter, mean-spirited but hilarious insults, and even more clever plotting.
The supporting cast really shines. Stephen Fry’s Lord Melchett and Tim McInnerny’s Lord Percy are perfect foils, and Richardson’s Queenie is both unpredictable and next-level cool. You can tell everyone is having fun, making for episodes that burst with energy and laughs.
If witty dialogue and sharp character interactions are your thing, Blackadder II takes the crown. It’s loaded with memorable one-liners, plot twists, and the ever-escalating battle of wits between Blackadder and his endlessly optimistic but hopelessly clueless sidekick, Baldrick.
Blackadder the Third: Subtle, Smart, and Smooth
The move to Regency England brings a new mood. Now, Blackadder works as a scheming butler to the totally oblivious Prince Regent (played to perfection by Hugh Laurie). The comedy turns more deadpan, with a lot of satire poking at the silly traditions and self-importance of the upper class. Blackadder is in command, and he’s every bit as manipulative as you’d hope.
Bringing Hugh Laurie into the main cast adds a fresh spark. The ongoing jokes about the Prince Regent’s open cluelessness and Baldrick’s attempts at “cunning plans” deliver laughs episode after episode. The mix of period settings and snarky writing makes this series stand out, especially if you favor dry humor and social satire.
Blackadder Goes Forth: Black Comedy With Real Heart
Setting a comedy in WWI trenches sounds risky, but Blackadder Goes Forth pulls it off brilliantly. Atkinson’s Blackadder takes on the role of Captain, desperate to escape both the war and the madness around him. The jokes are as clever as ever, but the mood is darker, with the pointlessness of war looming large. The heart comes through strongest here, especially as the final episode approaches.
This series gets quoted more than any other at fan gatherings, and the ending is legendary for good reason. If you want a sitcom that can bring both farce and a gut punch, Blackadder Goes Forth is hard to beat.
My Picks: The Highs (And a Few Lows)
Everyone’s got their favorites, but here’s my take on what stands out across Blackadder’s run:
- Sharpest Dialogue: Blackadder II wins hands down, with some of the most perfectly timed barbs and exchanges ever written for TV.
- Best Supporting Cast: Blackadder Goes Forth, especially with Stephen Fry as General Melchett and Hugh Laurie as George adding real depth.
- Easiest to Rewatch: Blackadder the Third. Episodes like “Nob and Nobility” and “Duel and Duality” never get old.
- Wackiest Comedy: The Black Adder (Series 1). It’s scrappy and faulted, but that’s part of the fun if you love slapstick and wild costumes.
Comparing Key Elements in Each Series
Need help picking your favorite? Here’s how the main features stack up and what you might keep in mind for your own Blackadder debates:
- Historical Setups: All four series play with history for comedic effect. Costumes and sets change dramatically—from chainmail to fancy ruffs and WWI uniforms—giving every series a unique visual stamp.
- Chemistry Between the Leads: Blackadder and Baldrick’s partnership grows and changes each series, maturing from a goofy prince/servant combo to a more efficient but still doomed duo by the last run.
- Sitcom Flavor: The first series turns up the physical gags, but later series lean on smarter, word-based humor and great character interactions.
- Famous Guests: The likes of Stephen Fry, Hugh Laurie, Miranda Richardson, and Tim McInnerny keep things lively across all four series.
Things to Keep in Mind When Picking a Favorite
- Comedy Style: If you love fast-paced jokes and lots of clever insults, Blackadder II and III will be your cup of tea. For classic, slapstick laughs, the first series is great.
- Emotional Weight: Blackadder Goes Forth pulls at the heartstrings while still going for big laughs, especially as the finale nears.
- Production Value: The later series are flashier, with smoother sets and more developed visuals. You’ll notice the boost if you marathon the series.
The First Series: Why It’s Divisive
The original Blackadder series is a love-it-or-hate-it situation. Some folks enjoy the broad jokes, experimental feel, and outlandish characters, while others think it lags or feels uneven. The medieval setting and early 80s low-budget feel give it a rough charm that some can’t resist. It’s definitely the odd one out, but there’s plenty to enjoy if you’re a fan of anything offbeat.
The Strengths of Later Series
With Blackadder II, III, and Goes Forth, the writing, characters, and comedic rhythm settle in, creating a gold standard for British sitcoms. These are the series I recommend for newcomers, because they stick to a reliable formula and deliver consistently big laughs with great acting.
Frequently Asked Questions About Blackadder
Is Blackadder historically accurate?
While the show pulls names and settings from actual history, it twists and distorts details purely for comedy. Accuracy is out the window—everything serves the joke!
Where can I watch Blackadder now?
The series pops up often on BritBox and Amazon Prime Video, plus it’s easily found as a full DVD boxset. UKTV Gold sometimes airs re-runs, so keep an eye out for it there.
Should I watch in order?
You don’t have to, but it helps. Watching from series one lets you spot character shifts, joke evolution, and running gags. Plus, the later series pay off more if you know each era’s quirks.
The Verdict: Which Blackadder Series Is Best?
Picking the ultimate Blackadder series boils down to your comedy taste. Blackadder II is my top pick for non-stop laughs and iconic dialogue. Blackadder the Third scores high if you love witty social satire. For depth and emotional balance, Blackadder Goes Forth steals the show, especially with its unforgettable finale. And though the original series plays things broader, it’s got a unique old-school vibe that still holds up for vintage comedy fans.
No matter where you start, Blackadder delivers—clever wordplay, wild costumes, and Baldrick’s wildly questionable plans are all up for grabs. The best Blackadder series is whichever one clicks for you most. You really can’t go wrong jumping in anywhere along the ride.